Over the years, the search for exoplanets has shown that
exoplanets vary enormously in size, mass, composition, and nearly every
conceivable parameter. Many of the discoveries were surprising and unexpected. Even
so, rocky planets are not known to exceed ~10 times the mass of Earth. It is
believed that a more massive rocky planet would have such an enormous
gravitational pull that it would accrete a gas envelope during formation and
end up either as an ice giant like Neptune or a gas giant like Jupiter. All
that changed when Dumusque et al. (2014) reported the discovery of the first
bona fide rocky planet with a mass exceeding 10 times the mass of Earth. “We
were very surprised when we realized what we had found,” says astronomer Xavier
Dumusque of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, who led the data
analysis and made the discovery.
Kepler-10 is a Sun-like star located 560 light years away in
the constellation of Draco. It hosts two transiting planets - Kepler-10b and
Kepler-10c. Both planets were detected by NASA’s Kepler space telescope and
their discoveries were announced in 2011. Based on how much light from its
parent star each transiting planet blocks, Kepler-10b is estimated to be 1.47
times the Earth’s diameter, while Kepler-10c is 2.35 times the Earth’s
diameter. The orbital periods of Kepler-10b and Kepler-10c are 20.1 hours and
45.3 days, respectively. It is clear from the orbital periods that both planets
are rather close-in to their parent star, especially Kepler-10b. The
equilibrium temperature on Kepler-10b is a searing 2169 K, while the
equilibrium temperature on Kepler-10c is a far cooler 584 K, albeit still a few
times the boiling temperature of water.
Kepler-10b is actually the first confirmed rocky planet to
be discovered outside the Solar System. With its aforementioned size and a
measured mass of 3.33 ± 0.49 Earth-masses, Kepler-10b has a density of 5.8 ± 0.8
g/cm³. For comparison, the density of Earth is 5.515 g/cm³. However, the mass
of the second planet, Kepler-10c, remains unknown until Dumusque et al. (2014) used
the HARPS-North instrument on the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo in the Canary
Islands to measure the gravitational “tugging” Kepler-10c exerts on its parent
star. The mass of Kepler-10c turns out to be 17.2 ± 1.9 Earth-masses. With its
size and mass known, the density of Kepler-10c is 7.1 ± 1.0 g/cm³, making it
the first confirmed rocky planet with more than 10 times Earth’s mass.
Kepler-10c is clearly an outlier in the mass-radius diagram
(Figure 4). Its bulk composition is dominated by rocky material (i.e.
silicates) and a significant amount of water amounting to between 5 to 20
percent of the planet’s mass. Most of the water is expected to be in the form
of exotic high-pressure ices. Moreover, the host star of Kepler-10c is an old
star that formed 10.6 billion years ago, when the universe was only 3 billion
years old. Back then, heavy elements such as the iron and silicon required to
form rocky planets were less common. The discovery of Kepler-10c shows that
rocky planets can readily form early in the universe’s history. This is
favourable for life since Earth itself is a rocky planet.
The news release by the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for
Astrophysics calls Kepler-10c a “mega-Earth”. This is because Kepler-10c is
well above the upper limit of 10 Earth-masses that is commonly used for the
term “super-Earth”. Besides, the term “mega-Earth” seems to have caught on
pretty well. It is likely that Kepler-10c is the first bona fide example of a
population of rocky planets with masses exceeding 10 times the mass of Earth. Another
planet, Kepler-131b, lies around the same location on the mass-radius diagram
as Kepler-10c (Figure 4). However, the mass of Kepler-131b is not known
accurately enough to confirm whether it is indeed a rocky planet. Kepler-131b
has a mass of 16.1 ± 3.5 Earth-masses and 2.4 ± 0.2 times the Earth’s diameter.
Figure 2: Transit light curves of Kepler-10b (left) and
Kepler-10c (right) along with the best-fit models. Dumusque et al. (2014).
Figure 4: Mass-radius diagram for planets smaller than 4 Earth-radii
and that present a mass determination better than 30 percent. The only
exception are the planets from the Kepler-11 planetary system that are shown
here because they have raised the issue that there may be planets with extended
envelopes of hydrogen and helium even at masses less than 5 times the Earth’s
mass. Filled symbols are used when the precision on the mass is better than 20
percent, highlighting measurements where an in-depth analysis of the planet
composition can be done. On the mass-radius diagram, Kepler-10c is the only
high-density planet more massive than 10 Earth-masses for which the precision
in mass is better than 20 percent. Dumusque et al. (2014).
Enormously massive rocky planets can also form from the
remnant cores of evaporated gas giant planets. This class of planets was
proposed by Hebrard et al. (2003) and are called “Chthonian” planets. A gas
giant planet that is in a close-in orbit around its parent star (i.e. a
hot-Jupiter) can experience sufficient heating and tidal forces that can cause
its layers of hydrogen and helium to be stripped away, leaving behind a remnant
rocky core. Although a gas giant planet’s rocky core generally makes up only a
small fraction of the planet’s total mass, it can still be up to tens of Earth-masses,
and possibly more. At such close proximity to its parent star, a Chthonian
planet is most probably tidally-locked, with a permanent dayside and nightside.
The planet’s dayside would be a blistering inferno and the glare from its
illuminated surface would be blinding, hundreds of times brighter than desert
sands at noontime on Earth. A lava ocean and possibly even pools of molten
metal may be present on the hellish dayside.
Observations from NASA’s Kepler space telescope have turned
up three planets that could be Chthonian planets. The three planets, Kepler-52b,
Kepler-52c and Kepler-57b, have maximum masses between 30 and 100 times the
mass of Earth, as determined via transit timing variations (TTVs) by Steffen et
al. (2012). Nevertheless, the planets are each only around twice Earth’s
diameter. If their true masses are indeed close to their estimated maximum
masses, then their densities would be larger than an iron planet of the same
size. These high-density planets could represent the naked cores of gas giant
planets that have lost their hydrogen-helium layers. After the formation of a
gas giant planet, its stupendous layers of hydrogen and helium “crushes” the
central solid core under extraordinarily high pressures, compressing the solid
core to higher densities. The results from a study by Mocquet at al. (2014)
show that the solid core left behind following the evaporation of a gas giant
planet can remain in its compressed state for billions of years.
Figure 5: Artist’s impression of a gas giant planet.
A study by Seager et al. (2007) suggests that massive O and
B stars with 5 to 120 times the mass of the Sun can have very hefty
protoplanetary disks containing large amounts of heavy elements. The strong UV
radiation and stellar winds from these stars can photo-evaporate the volatiles
from their protoplanetary disks, leaving only the solid material behind. As a
result, massive solid planets with hundreds to thousands of times Earth’s mass
may be able to form around these massive stars. The gravity on the surface of
such a rocky behemoth can be crushingly huge. For example, a rocky planet with
an Earth-like composition but with 1000 times the Earth’s mass would be ~3 times
the Earth’s diameter and would have a surface gravity ~100 times stronger than
on Earth (Figure 8).
Figure 7: Artist’s impression of a rocky planet.
References:
- Dumusque et al. (2014), “The Kepler-10 planetary system
revisited by HARPS-N: A hot rocky world and a solid Neptune-mass planet”, arXiv:1405.7881
[astro-ph.EP]
- Hebrard et al. (2003), “Evaporation rate of hot Jupiters
and formation of Chthonian planets”, arXiv:astro-ph/0312384
- Steffen et al. (2012), “Transit Timing Observations from
Kepler: III. Confirmation of 4 Multiple Planet Systems by a Fourier-Domain
Study of Anti-correlated Transit Timing Variations”, arXiv:1201.5412
[astro-ph.EP]
- Mocquet at al. (2014), “Very high-density planets: a
possible remnant of gas giants”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal
Society A, Volume 372, No. 2014
- Seager et al. (2007), “Mass-Radius Relationships for Solid
Exoplanets”, arXiv:0707.2895 [astro-ph]